Yesterday, we had the unpleasant task of firing our Public Relations agency, Buzz PR. We fired them because they were spamming our customers. At Cleartrip, we do not spam our customers or anyone else, ever. Period. There is no negotiating this.
Here’s what happened.
At around 4 pm, we came across this Tweet from @jackerhack:
@cleartrip Got mailed by Perfect Relations again. This is really a Hotel California situation now. /cc: @surdattack @gonsalves_r
— Kiran Jonnalagadda (@jackerhack) December 4, 2012
We had provided @jackerhack’s email to Buzz PR a few months ago when we launched an update to our mobile site. As part of the launch, we had invited a few select bloggers and customers to our offices to give them a sneak preview of the product before it launched. Buzz PR coordinated these invites for us, that’s why we gave them the email addresses of these bloggers and customers.
Buzz PR then proceeded to amalgamate the email addresses of our contacts and customers into their own email announcements list. These people, who trusted us, soon started receiving all kinds of emails from Buzz PR that had nothing to do with Cleartrip.
Prior to yesterday, @jackerhack had pointed out to us on two separate occasions that he was being spammed by Buzz PR. On each of those occasions we had strong words with Buzz PR and asked them to ensure this never happened again. Yesterday, it happened again.
There was no point in having another conversation with Buzz PR asking them to stop this. Around 7 pm, we sent them a brief email firing them. Three strikes.
We’re drawing a line in the sand here — we do not and will not spam our customers. Ever. And we certainly will not tolerate any of our partners spamming them. We’re only sorry we gave them three strikes, we should have fired them sooner.
And to everyone else that ever received spammy emails from Buzz PR because we shared your email address with them, we’re deeply sorry. None of our future partners will ever make this mistake again.
Appreciate your honesty guys. And thank you for clearing out what is informative and what is spam.
I salute you for having the conviction to stand by your principles. Wish more companies were like this.
And this is exactly why I love you guys =D
@Cleartrip Respect!
@Cleartrip You should stick to real PR pros. I.e. @MUSTARDPR & @DP_Walsh
@StefanBielau @MUSTARDPR Thanks Stefan. Great move @Cleartrip
@niksypixie http://t.co/5e2PODIz
Hope others learn! RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/9nhpDTVl
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
Fair point, depending on how true it was “@Miss_nautanki:So, @Cleartrip clears its stance on why did it fire its #PR.. http://t.co/ucYtyFzI“
RT @MumbaiCentral: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/FuVNEucf via @Cleartrip
Bravo! RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/EUkrEhEU
RT @rajatagr: Wish all companies did what @cleartrip did. Part of PR is you never spam your customers/media. http://t.co/qYmcZMBT
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/71HzCMQO
RT @_Schnapped: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/WcebgBFe via @Cleartrip
@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/XF8B3QmT
RT @MumbaiCentral: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/FuVNEucf via @Cleartrip
RT @tinucherian: Why we fired our PR agency #BuzzPR ? http://t.co/1QnItJnx via @Cleartrip #PublicRelations | Interesting!
Hmmm. RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/lOD8eyjV
Wow! Way to go, Hrush!
Well done, Cleartrip. I wish all companies started handling their own PR. Outsourcing it to spammy/ethically challenged agencies is not the right way.
Lesson for all those who think spamming is easy marketing …
It’s great to see a spotless work ethic. Hard to find otherwise. Really appreciate and Thanks.
Nice work guys.
And that is why I totally love you @Cleartrip.
sorry, i disagree with you not spamming, i have had mails and even calls saying they have my number from your website.
How dumb of Buzz PR not to take the warnings seriously. And how dumb of @ClearTrip to announce it. Both professionally wrong. Both at fault!
I don’t think it was dumb of Cleartrip to announce this. They have a right to clarify that the Spam emails their Customers received was a mistake by their PR agency and that it won’t happen again.
I agree
Understood on firing Buzz. Firing them publicly; not so much.
Totally agree.
Looks like somebody didn’t like Buzz in the client’s office!
It’s honest moves like this that helps keep businesses honest. Thank you for this righteous move. I hope all others who currently practice spam are warned as well.
@james_priya http://t.co/OgKdFwl0
RT @arifkhan7: Why we (@Cleartrip) fired our PR agency? http://t.co/IjmMcFQ2
Buzz PR and Cleartrip -> RT @madhuchhanda11 @james_priya http://t.co/wKXTYdaf
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
I’m impressed *Teary eyes*
@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. What happened ?: http://t.co/dIM0smZw
++1 RT @aneeshb Impressive “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/zHzOQY07”
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/uC3sfUHB via @Cleartrip
Much respect for you guys! “Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/9AaN6hvu via @Cleartrip”
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/5Ve15fHZ
Finally someone taking steps against spamming – (Just wish there isn’t an ugly side to this story from the PR… http://t.co/4UD6KXif
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
@Cleartrip #Respect. Very few companies live up to their laid principles. And you are a true inspiration. “We fired our PR agency yesterday”
Wow! That’s why I use (and will) CT
Brilliant –As a customer i would like to say THANK YOU…
I’m the @jackerhack referenced in the tweet above.
I’m not sure how BuzzPR and Perfect Relations are related. All the email I got was signed off by Perfect Relations.
I’ve asked them more than once to unsubscribe me, and they replied confirming that I’ve been unsubscribed. After the third time, someone even called to apologise and said it won’t happen again. And then I got mailed again yesterday.
Correction: the original mail for the Cleartrip event was from BuzzPR. Everything else was Perfect Relations.
Perfect Relations is the only company spamming me at that particular email address, and it started after the Cleartrip event.
I’m given to understand the two companies are related, and if this is true, I fully commend Cleartrip for firing their agency.
Buzz PR is a sister company of Perfect Relations.
A big round of applause for Clear trip ladies and gentlemen. They certainly deserve it. Kudos
RT @tinucherian: Why we fired our PR agency #BuzzPR ? http://t.co/1QnItJnx via @Cleartrip #PublicRelations | Interesting!
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @MumbaiCentral: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/FuVNEucf via @Cleartrip
@flirtytango Hehe here you go http://t.co/N8fqwv8H
A big round of applause for @cleartrip ladies and gentlemen. They certainly deserve it. Kudos http://t.co/j6wlSoP0
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
spamming can lead you lose your client! http://t.co/O3LMv86x via @Cleartrip
RT @monikamanchanda: A big round of applause for @cleartrip ladies and gentlemen. They certainly deserve it. Kudos http://t.co/j6wlSoP0
RT @MumbaiCentral: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/FuVNEucf via @Cleartrip
“@monikamanchanda: A big round of applause for @cleartrip ladies and gentlemen. They certainly deserve it. Kudos http://t.co/1OR7yFDK”
@Cleartrip There is something called #Corporateethics. There was no need of making it public. #LamePRstunt
@Dinesh_B_Sharma @Cleartrip Don’t think so. They’re justified in letting customers know how this happened & that it won’t happen again.
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
Exactly what I was trying to figure out after reading the post.
But good call, Cleartrip. Just hope you haven’t fired the wrong guys.
Saket,
Buzz PR is a sister company of Perfect Relations
My last comment is a reply to Kiran’s comment – not sure why doesn’t show up as that.
Hopefully this is a deterrent for others. Good one Hrush. Best, Emmanuel
People butthurt about @cleartrip not being “professional.” They got bad service, they blogged about it. Don’t we all do that?
RT @monikamanchanda: A big round of applause for @cleartrip ladies and gentlemen. They certainly deserve it. Kudos http://t.co/S42fIRFP
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/NiIQulVI via @Cleartrip
I am a Cleartripper and I vouch for their ‘no spam’ policy RT @ozzmancometh07:Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/3vyoeV91 via @Cleartrip
Clap clap #nospam “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/t3D0UyiG“
RT @nigelbabu: Hats off to @cleartrip: http://t.co/wuNwkS4a
RT @nixxin: #respect for @Cleartrip for firing BuzzPR http://t.co/2f3zxgoH If all companies did this, all PR agencies would be out of biz
Why we fired our PR company: http://t.co/wR7Yg0CF
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/RvSe9Rwd
Just wondering which PR agency is handling this
RT “@saxena_ashes: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/bVxV3U4L via @Cleartrip”
[...] Travel booking service Cleartrip claims to maintain strict policy of not sending customers unwanted emails. This is central to the firing of Buzz PR, Cleartrip explained in a blog post. [...]
well done
This. Awesome. RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/EFniX6kw
@MaliZomg This is outstanding. Gotta love honest businesses. @Cleartrip
@danielmarcevans @Cleartrip Yep. Very impressed. Would love to use ClearTrip now that I know they won’t promote my personal details.
@MaliZomg It’s very impressive. I run all digital stuff at our company and ‘honesty is the best policy’ is the words I live by @Cleartrip
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/DJqCsVSd via @Cleartrip
@Cleartrip That’s a very strong statement against spam – Respect!
[...] Travel booking service Cleartrip claims to maintain strict policy of not sending customers unwanted emails. This is central to the firing of Buzz PR, Cleartrip explained in a blog post. [...]
Slow clapping. “@Cleartrip We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/uA4oZD6t“
@Cleartrip Highly respect your stand on spamming. “Three strikes” is a little too cowboy for your stature.
@mojorojo
#Cleartrip.com #Fires #BuzzPR For Spamming Its Customers…! Here’s What really happened… http://blog.cleartrip.com/2012/12/05/why-we-fired-our-pr-agency/#comments
Cleartrip, you were on top of the list already. But this – http://t.co/qxSK9WRu – is why you stay there. @cleartrip
The people claiming that @cleartrip was wrong in firing Buzz PR publicly most probably are PR professionals | http://t.co/RQ8eROBc
How awesome is it that @Cleartrip was able to generate PR by firing their PR firm?
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RESPECT! Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/izI7dcN4 via @Cleartrip
RT @SaysMaverick: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/To4UO4A9 via @Cleartrip
Some clown calling himself a “digital evangelist” says @cleartrip’s blog has done “more harm.” Do a sentiment analysis of tweets, then talk.
Certain banks need to learn from Cleartrip
/ Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/izI7dcN4 via @Cleartrip
Excellent. Most firms only say, but don’t actually believe in the “no spamming” ethic, forget taking positive action on preventing it. You’re the most unusual client. I salute you.
RT @chromemachine: #Cleartrip.com #Fires #BuzzPR For Spamming Its Customers…! Here’s What really happened…… http://t.co/ioikh6vQ
How Not To Do PR: http://t.co/zUx5XDvF via @Cleartrip
RT @joshibhuvi: Why @Cleartrip fired their PR agency http://t.co/E9HjhpDR
@amithpr @senjam Check out http://t.co/Sx0i5krV #ClearTrip #BuzzPR #PublicRelations
This shows how sad Cleartrip PR or marketing team is. Firing the agency is upto them but publicizing it in a bad light reflects how vindictive they are. There are ways to do it but not take it to a public forum. Bad culture.
Look at this the other way.
I get spammed by lots of CT emails directly coming from CT. I Ignore them and move on. Period.
Every Emailer has a hyperlink to click if you donot wish to receive such spam mails in future. You click it… the sender gets alert on that and your Mail ID gets removed from the list. If every time it’s manual effort, you reply back to the sender and I am sure they back out.
Lets come to the issue. Professional decision to fire Buzz PR. ETHICAL and SUPERB. Publicly announcing it? NOT ETHICAL.
Sharing Customers’ data to test new app with Buzz PR … UNETHICAL… CT should have used own resources to do that. How many calls and followups would you have to do for that anyways?
And now CT announces publicly that they shared that bit of data but they have not told what is the % of data or what number of customers’ data have been compromised. Isn’t it ETHICAL for CT to issue atleast a simple APOLOGY to those who suffered?
In my opinion CT is as guilty as Buzz PT in this.
As interesting as the turn of events between both organisations I am sure this will be an interesting Case Study which will be debated over the period of time.
If someone has reply/clarification from Buzz PR please share.
Anand — we shared the email addresses because everyone we invited ran news blogs. Some of them also just happened to be customers. We did not invite anyone who was a customer, but not a news blogger.
Bloggers, in general, write about general topics and would welcome invitations to try out new apps etc. In this instance, these particular bloggers were chosen to review one app, and the company who facilitated the review believed the bloggers, in all fair interest, might be interested in reviewing further such products. If you are not interested, you just politely say ‘no thanks.’
If you do not want to be a part of the information sharing, one would simply mark mails as spam. Why point fingers at a particular company who were just trying to do their job?
PR, as a function, involves some sharing of information. So even if you were a reporter once upon a time, your email ID gets shared long after you’ve moved on and you get a fair amount of mails from PR people and other companies. In this case, the blogger was perhaps added to the same list.
And for ClearTrip to be making such a public announcement of their PR partner just shows extreme bad taste and a lame attempt at earning brownie points from its customers who they have spammed earlier directly.
Good guy @ cleartrip
http://t.co/XaPhvCAh
RT @writetopiyush: Brilliant move- Why we fired our PR agency –> http://t.co/KcYAfQLX
Audacious or Smart? “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/dZaJoUuc“
I’ll stop giving @cleartrip my business in a personal capacity for being inhuman, arrogant and silly about a business partner. Bad handling
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/sEAg2zZ1 via @Cleartrip
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @amithpr: Audacious or Smart? “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/dZaJoUuc“
I wish more companies would sack their PR agency for spamming. much <3 for @Cleartrip for setting the right example.
Respect !! haven’t seen a company being so open regarding such issues ! respect to that !
A broad question. Considering many PR agencies are privy to information regarding their clients that could impact end customers/users, can they also warn the client twice about such practices and then fire them in the 3rd instance… and blog about it?
proud of you @cleartrip . You are one of the few brands who work FOR the customers.
“awesomeness” there’s no substitute – http://t.co/l0a2Z2KK
an #Ecommerce #website that understands customer grievances. Good Show @Cleartrip No tolerating #Spam.
http://t.co/ALVtk2RO
Isn’t this violation of Corporate Ethics and Policy? Cleartrip had to hire the agency but to announce it publicly is being too desperate to get some coverage. Bad move.
Seeing the coverage that Cleartrip got after firing it PR agency. I shd write about client drama, i might hve a best seller in my hand.
Only people who’ve worked in PR seem to be outraging over cleartrip’s idea of announcing it to the public, rest all seem to be applauding.
Adding more… For the first time I hear a PR agency managing customer communications directly. Well, the PR agency should have been hired by Cleartrip based on their expertize. I would not share my customer database to a PR furm rather employ a separate marketing agency. From Cleartrips desperation, it looks like they are puncing on a soft target to hide their bad management.
completely agreed! are’nt there other companies who specialise is CRM? why was the PR agency mandated to do that, if that is the case?
They were mandated to reach out to news bloggers for a product launch. Some of those bloggers just also happened to be customers.
Hrush,
In the PR circle if they asked for you can easily get a Bloggers’ list. You donot have to share the details with them.
I don’t agree with you Anand.
Agencies are very very tight-fisted with their contact information.
They would not share their media lists – even bloggers
Some how i think what @cleartrip has done has thrown open a pandora’s box – leave alone the merits of what Buzz PR did, one is surprised at the contempt with which an image partner is publicly humiliated. Customer is king, yes, but is’nt the PR agency a reverse customer in a sense?!
Its also common across industries to make use of database (contact information) sourced from all and sundry. This is widely prevalent in India.
Confusing trend indeed!?
PR’s need to rescue their own reputation. Today’s #Cleartrip incident is another reminder that things are not all right.
While you may well have done good with firing your agency on account of non-compliance with your company values, but public disclosure may not have been the best way to deal with it.
Bravo! Refreshing to see such high ethical standards in this time and age.
All respects to ClearTrip… You guys have won thousands of hearts with your honest effort in this country which lacks it deeply.. ClearTrip will certainly be my first choice when I travel next. All the best guys !!
[...] RT @arifkhan7: Why we (@Cleartrip) fired our PR agency? [...]
Even if someone is wrong, showcasing it to the world does not show you in good light. What you did might be right but talking your partner good or bad is not. Do you promote and applaud your partners in public?
Way to go guys!!! Now that’s a really good example of ‘walking the talk’. Cheers.
Here’s @Cleartrip on why it has fired its PR agency Buzz PR. | http://t.co/46AV10d2 … via @dhira_joan
Free and effective PR move. Bad business ethics. I am surprised there is not a single ‘other side story’ in this entire chain…
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @ShivAroor: Here’s @Cleartrip on why it has fired its PR agency Buzz PR. | http://t.co/46AV10d2 … via @dhira_joan
RT @rajatagr: Wish all companies did what @cleartrip did. Part of PR is you never spam your customers/media. http://t.co/qYmcZMBT
I believe its a marketing strategy well thought of by clear trip. by announcing the sacking of their PR agency on Social Media, the company stands to gain credibility that they don’t spam. whatever said and done I guess hiring and sacking of a PR / marketing agency is an internal affair and need not be published in open forum.
RT @rotalks: Nice! RT “@gauravkapur: Read this guys. Good job Cleartrip RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s why http://t.co/eMJPnwQv”
Hi
RT @binoyxj: RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/m1lBkLd3
I applaud your commitment and focus to your customers/contacts!!
How ethical it is to speak about it publicly.. clear trip needs to understand a term called “Corporate Ethics”
true that!
Bravo! RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/ZBivmboY
RT @gauravkapur: Read this guys. Good job Cleartrip RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/M3HmXriZ
RT @behindthespin: Now that’s how to get a blaze of positive publicity: fire your agency http://t.co/a0e1vKRt #nospam (NB direct marketing is not #PR)
@Cleartrip we respect this
i think u got enough sales mileage by firing ur PR agency. Happy selling @Cleartrip .. U think we are don’t understand publicity tactics??
Good move. And by making a big deal about it you get PR and save retainer fees
@Cleartrip Isn’t this unethical?? you could have done it just the way you hired them.
@Sumbad29 @cleartrip somehow i dnt like the sound of it. FIRED. seems they are blowing their own trumpet n victory over evil cald spamming.
@Sumbad29 @cleartrip @richa_bhardwaj nothing really to be put on ur blog and be proud of it.
@cleartrip ethics are nowhere seen in your story!!
Awesome guys
@monikamanchanda @Cleartrip i had terrible experience with them
Will not be surprised if this right here, in itself, is one of the most brilliant PR campaigns in a long time. If it is, pity Buzz PR won’t even be able to take credit for it.
Wow glad someone took email spamming seriously! Read this – “Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/cdlNqmm6 via @Cleartrip”
Would love to hear the PR agency’s version of the story | Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/zy50J7IS
Big blogger relations #prfail http://t.co/SfGfqSA3 > should have read the ebook: http://t.co/Bu9Vx57w @Cleartrip
@hughforth Wow, @cleartrip not messing around there. But fair enough..
RT @kanupriyasindhu: Wow glad someone took email spamming seriously! Read this – “Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/cdlNqmm6 via @Cleartrip”
Why @cleartrip fires their PR agency #ILike http://t.co/ggEiKYoJ
This is interesting: “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/P4D4fLeC
RT @MissMalini: #BuzzKillPR
“@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/4GIMusQR“
*Slow Clap* RT @aneeshb “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/SdzxjLp6 ”
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/jjfeZ5Wy <–Respect!
Holding by the balls! RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/ANryNUVc
Good one! http://t.co/35q4OQVf
RT @gauravkapur: Read this guys. Good job Cleartrip RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/M3HmXriZ
RT @shilpakannan: This is interesting: “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/P4D4fLeC
I m truly impressed RT @Cleartrip We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/DZmtPwMh
RT @behindthespin: Now that’s how to get a blaze of positive publicity: fire your agency http://t.co/a0e1vKRt #nospam (NB direct marketing is not #PR)
Great!
I do think though that just the name itself of the PR agency could have been omitted. Wouldn’t want our favorite travel company to face a defamation lawsuit, would we?
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/afzGhhos via @Cleartrip
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @therealprmoment: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/uk03m5vK <- aggressive approach from @cleartrip.
RT: #BuzzKillPR
“@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/4nnEk3YQ “
I’m sure that created a lot of buzz! Bohohaha @MaliZomg @Cleartrip
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
You nailed it! – RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/fTMePYgM #fb
My take and thoughts on the whole controversy shared here http://dreamingcherries.com/2012/12/how-did-cleartrip-mishandle-the-firing-of-its-publicrelations-agency-buzzpr/
RT @anshumgupta: Why I #love and #respect how #Cleartrip operates RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/VAuEORne
Laughing at the PR “professionals” that are colluding to spin this Cleartrip thing their way. And failing. Good reason not to hire them!
Mr. Hrush from Cleartrip goes ahead and apologizes and takes full responsibility for this post and for naming the agency publicly in a comment on a blogpost by BeastOfTraal (Read Post here: http://bit.ly/UeyJmI) . *Read Full comment below.
My questions:
1. If you have gone ahead with writing this entire post and getting your blog followers to read this, should you not now also post an apology here? If the maligning started form the this platform here, shouldn’t the apology also be made here on your official blog?
2. Doesn’t this apology also clarify that what you did was also unethical and unprofessional all at once? So for one who is trying to say that the agency was wrong somewhere, how right was this act by cleartrip?
Complete comment by Hrush:
“Hi Karthik — thank you for this post.
Integrity is one of our foundational values at Cleartrip; it is something we cherish deeply. We do not sacrifice it for the sake of revenue or growth or profit or spam. And when we saw a marketing partner taking our values so lightly, it hurt.
This will sound surprising coming from me, but I agree with what you’ve said above. I should not have named the PR agency in our blog post. There was no need for that whatsoever.
Whether anyone chooses to believe it or not, we had no intention of making this public at all until CNBC’s @BrandStoryboard Twitter handle picked it up. At that time, we realised that it was going to kickstart a discussion and we wanted to share our side of the story.
We don’t have a “social media team” at Cleartrip, it’s just a part of everyones’ job. Sometimes, it’s a part of my job; and this blog post was written in its entirety by me, no one else at Cleartrip even had the chance to look at it before it went live. I take responsibility for every word.
Do I regret naming the agency in the post? Yes, I do.
It was something done in the heat of the moment — partly out of anger and partly out of hurt that a marketing partner would be so dismissive of our values. Haven’t we all done things in the heat of a moment that we later regret?
I even considered removing the agency name after the post had gone live; but the only thing that would have achieved is a bunch of people saying we were camouflaging what we originally said as a form of damage control. What was done, was done; and I decided it was better to leave the post unchanged and live with consequences.
I am sorry I named the agency in the post, but I’m not sorry that we fired them.”
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/BrUaJl6L via @Cleartrip
RT @dreamcarousel: *Slow Clap* RT @aneeshb “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/SdzxjLp6 ”
RT @pradeepchopra: Seems to be a new crisis emerging in an attempt to manage the previous one for Cleartrip: http://t.co/XJ6qZoSD.
RT @kanikaabhatia: OKAY @CLEARTRIP – YOU #WIN. http://t.co/Y0kwczXw #bestbusinesspolicy #saynotoSPAM
@cleartrip…. not that cleartrip has never screwed up with their customers. chk one complaint
ClearTrip (complaint)
rajesh shahca on Sep 30, 2012
air ticket booking
LEGAL NOTICE SENT TO CLEARTRIP WHO HAD CHEATED ME IN BOOKING MY TICKET TO TIRUPATHI: KINDLY INTERVENE AND CMPENSATE ME WITH THE LOSS SUSTAINED BY ME. Legal Notice Date:-23/09/2012 The Principal Officer, Stuart Crighton – Founder and Chief Executive Officer Cleartrip Travel Services Pvt Ltd Unit No…
@cleartrip If u can apologize for this on another blog, y not apologize on official blog? http://bit.ly/UeyJmI #HrushMakeItClear
Just as Cleartrip fired their PR agency for spamming customers, there is another big company that need to fire theirs. http://t.co/hjhkDvnU
RT @Quainto: And why spamming can be a serious issue! @Cleartrip
http://t.co/do6z7DI8
RT @amithasingh: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/BrUaJl6L via @Cleartrip
Sets an example for sure: http://t.co/UIyYXeKP
Why we fired our PR agency :: Clearly ClearTrip http://t.co/2Rhhd6M5 via @undrip
Take a Stand against spamming. http://t.co/lth9m8BD
The Sam Manekshaw of online booking. RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/mvVuyD62
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/jRRpSFf5 via @Cleartrip [Set A Good Example]
This @Cleartrip issue is still on. One cannot even do a good thing these days without creating a controversy. Anyway, good job cleartrip.
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/jRRpSFf5 via @Cleartrip [I am sure Dr.Batra would like to hire that agency]
Brave Move,but a little stupid.A new drama unfolds RT@Cleartrip We fired our PR agency yesterday,here’s what happened: http://t.co/bPhWZlGY
RT @priyankawriting: Cleartrip fires PR agency http://t.co/oWcAKB7D .. being spammed for years in the same way from @2020MSL
@Cleartrip firing #BuzzPR in public, was this right? Just a though, whole story @ http://t.co/6B9BYlci
RT @Brajeshwar: Just as Cleartrip fired their PR agency for spamming customers, there is another big company that need to fire theirs. http://t.co/hjhkDvnU
Nice move by @Cleartrip.. RT @MumbaiCentral: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/ARYhbwgE via @Cleartrip
I…LOVE this: ”Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/dMSVU6zL via @Cleartrip” Shout out to ‘PR professionals’ in Dubai: take notice.
Public ridicule for a spamming PR Firm is the right thing. Well done #cleartrip #BuzzPR
#Cleartrip is good. They took a stand. Like it or hate it is one thing. Boycott them? no way! @SahilRiz @madmanweb
Surprised to not see more discussion on this – Company announces firing of PR on their blog agency http://t.co/9WYYm5bI
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/6mwbRODy. @Cleartrip Might get a customer next time I need a ticket.
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/Sc46GVOw
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/lHjuV7am
Why Cleartrip fired their PR agency http://t.co/5LCbXNAW
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/8OvsHX2c via @Cleartrip
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
I appreciate the commitment of @Cleartrip to its customers.Certainly this will build a strong relationship with your customers.Keep it up!
Why we (Cleartrip) fired our PR agency http://t.co/jYGN04OO
HanmerMSL also needs a fix of this. Kudos @cleartrip! Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/xgNJFLoz
@twilightfairy @cleartrip what is the other side saying?
@mokshjuneja @cleartrip what is there to say? it is unethical to share mail addresses sought for one purpose, to spam for various purposes.
@twilightfairy @cleartrip but everyone works on database style, there isn’t a law regarding that
@mokshjuneja @cleartrip that doesn’t make it right! BTW there are laws against that in US. a mail id sought for one purpose can NOT be sold
@mokshjuneja @cleartrip and in my case Hanmer MSL not only started spamming me, a lot of other PR agencies suddenly got that id for spam!
RT @twilightfairy: HanmerMSL also needs a fix of this. Kudos @cleartrip! Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/xgNJFLoz
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/OzM1Zrhw via @Cleartrip
Cleartrip is one of the few companies, especially Indian, that have at least a modicum of ethics. http://t.co/cKbCPIhl (via @saurabhsahni)
Top story: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/gm239HU7, see more http://t.co/XtMg1DiQ
Nicely said! My classmates think this place have performed excellently!
Tht deserves an applause! http://t.co/LuGj0eyu via @Cleartrip
New-found respect for Cleartrip:
http://t.co/s8QHshn8
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/ENreF9d9 via @Cleartrip
Thats just too good! Way to go @cleartrip! …….Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/JTiVZZ2S
Bravo !!! Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/Y9sTzdt3
Wouhouuuuuuuuuuu!
@ShephaliBhatt http://t.co/MgJ4NtgJ Has the PR agency responded to this? how are existing clients taking this? #damage
Clear statement, resolute handling by @Cleartrip http://t.co/oHLX617W
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/evpZlbxO via @Cleartrip
RT @amrita_kumar: Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/evpZlbxO via @Cleartrip
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/Z9rzLPtz – this is “not cricket” IMHO
@cleartrip fired their PR agency http://t.co/dBoV94xS Great! Now they should fire some of their customer support agents and hire some humans
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/rxuQSN5U
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/zL1yeQ2Y
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/AbrSnAJi
Cleartrip fired its PR agency for spamming, a clear action against a breach of trust http://t.co/ZSf7t5jC via @Cleartrip
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/3ghqe7NM via @Cleartrip
RT @ramhv: Cleartrip fired its PR agency for spamming, a clear action against a breach of trust http://t.co/ZSf7t5jC via @Cleartrip
Interesting tidbit in the cleartrip v/s Buzz PR case; most people bemoaning the public sacking seem to be social media professionals.
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/nKRZzOEN RT @cleartrip, a need to understand social media n impact
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
A reason why I always book my flight tkts here”@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/mmocgocZ“
Hmmm.. RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/bGQbHK1Y
Some where some Jerry Maguire would be happy RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/ujxTwOb7 #PR
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
Well done! | Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/Vdvfy2ud
Nicely done! “@Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday for spamming our customers. Here’s what happened: http://t.co/h7A8r2Yy“
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/sTTkumAJ
AskGutsGo – Your thoughts on this please …. http://blog.cleartrip.com/2012/12/05/why-we-fired-our-pr-agency/
PR people generally connect mainly with the media, unless they include a marketing function. A PR agency’s role is to ensure media exposure – online, television and print and a few other forms. Some companies also handle social media and marketing.
The blanket mails we generally get, which we mark as spam, are from marketing companies and not PR agencies.
People, please learn the difference.
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
RT @Cleartrip: We fired our PR agency yesterday, here’s what happened: http://t.co/jb17Efpj
Here’s how Cleartrip threw it’s PR agency under the tour bus! (but seems they had it coming) – http://t.co/I4fYHvTj #PR
Why cleartrip fired their PR agency… Interesting case study for communication professionals: http://t.co/hAckLA1v
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/fqSMTtQw
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/ZyBEeeCw via @Cleartrip
Indeed a good step taken .
P.Gautmpurkar.Sawai Madhopur,Rajsthan
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/HS2Ro7KH
The perils of amalgamating customer contacts into PR mailing lists. You get fired… http://t.co/U9Fvyiox
Story of Dumb and Dumbers
RT @vimalpillai: Why cleartrip fired their PR agency… Interesting case study for communication professionals: http://t.co/hAckLA1v
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/PvkKHyR3 via @Cleartrip
Negative PR for a PR agency… Ouch! http://t.co/BqOiWqEq #wom
Cleartrip fires PR agency and then Blogs about it..your thoughts? #ccpr http://t.co/4LvuUk8e
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/7zkeuXKv via @Cleartrip
If u had been careful at the time of hiring the pr firm and done ur homework, this wud never hav happened. Issuing such a public justification is a fantastic pr and image building ploy, but including the name of your pr firm is actually slanderous. And then u announce how u waited for three strikes before showing them the door – do u realise how unconcerned and lethargic u sound? If the integrity of spamming was so critical and important to u, then u shud have fired them post the second transgression, not waited for the third strike. What u nid is a better pr firm that does not only provide u with media coverage but adds value beyond. But then, r u ready for such services? I doubt, cos u aint no different from the hundreds out there who think pr is just media coverage.
Cleartrip fires its PR agency. Read more..to learn WHY http://t.co/7krEqhr7 via @Cleartrip
RT @JoelTurner: The perils of amalgamating customer contacts into PR mailing lists. You get fired… http://t.co/U9Fvyiox
Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/z0tQUpVB @Cleartrip Respect! I love you guys!
@gavinhudson interesting update -Why we fired our PR agency http://t.co/EURf026P via @Cleartrip”
Why we fired our PR agency – honest tail of a douchey PR move. Thanks for sharing it @Sanju0703 @Cleartrip http://t.co/QV65cwqc
Para reflexionar > Cleartrip Blog: “¿Por qué despedimos a nuestra agencia de RP? http://t.co/1bYVPfVj
Looks like CT got more PR by firing their PR agency…nice PR work CT!